Browse Compare Prices New Releases Retailers

Dusting off the vinyl…

Find the best prices on vinyl records from major retailers and independent stores.

Browse

All Records
Today's Deals
New Releases
Genres

Account

Sign In
Create Account
My Wishlist
My Collection

Help

About Us
Retailer List

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. We may also earn commissions from other retailers linked on this site. Prices updated daily and may not reflect the current price — always verify on the retailer's site before purchasing.

© 2026 Vinyl Itch. All rights reserved.

Privacy Policy Terms of Service

Filters

to

In stock onlyMultiple stores onlyPre-orders only

Colored vinyl onlyAudiophile only

AllNewUsedSealed

Pop66Jazz18Funk / Soul9Stage & Screen5Rock3Folk, World, & Country2Electronic1

Vocal54Easy Listening18Ballad14Soul8Holiday6Disco5Soft Rock2Pop Rock2Soul-Jazz1Romantic1Rhythm & Blues1Theme1Gospel1Music Hall1

10,000 Hz Records1234Go RecordsAcoustic SoundsAlt PressAmazonAmoeba MusicAtlantic RecordsbandcampBlue Note RecordsBrooklyn VeganB-Side RecordsCapitol MusicCraft RecordingsCrazy Vinyl RecordsDarkside RecordsDef JamDon Giovanni RecordsDrowned World RecordsEasy Going RecordsExperience VinylFat BeatsFive Buck BinGet On DownGoner RecordsGood RecordsHi Voltage RecordsInner SleeveInterscope RecordsJosey RecordsLe NoiseLevitationLight in the AtticLunchbox RecordsMatador RecordsMondoMVD ShopNeedlejuice RecordsNewbury ComicsNH Vintage VinylNumero GroupOrbit RecordsPale Blue Dot RecordsPlaid Room RecordsPolyvinyl RecordsReb RecordsRecord StopRecord Town TXRed Yeti RecordsRelapse RecordsRepublic RecordsRevolver MagazineRhinoRise RecordsRock & Roll Hall of FameRollin RecsRough TradeRude RecordsSacred Bones RecordsSaddle CreekSecretly StoreShuga RecordsSky Valley RecordsSmartpunkSold Out Vinyl RecordsSolSta RecordsSony Music VinylSound of VinylSounds Like VinylSpotify BackfillSub Pop RecordsTargetThe 'In' GrooveThird Man RecordsTower RecordsTurntable LabuDiscover MusicUrban OutfittersVerve RecordsVinyl.comVinyl DevotionVinyl JunkiesVinyl Revival RecordsVinyl Tap NashvilleWalmartWarner Music StoreWax Bodega

Johnny Mathis

75 records

Artist: Johnny Mathis×In Stock Only×Clear all

Johnny Mathis With Nelson Riddle And His Orchestra - Live It Up!

Live It Up!

Johnny Mathis With Nelson Riddle And His Orchestra

$6.00$12.99

In Stock

Compare prices

Johnny Mathis - Love Is Blue

Love Is Blue

$1.95$4.95

In Stock

Compare prices

Johnny Mathis - Johnny Mathis Sings The Music Of Bacharach & Kaempfert

Johnny Mathis Sings The Music Of Bacharach & Kaempfert

$5.00$10.00

In Stock

Compare prices

Johnny Mathis - I'll Never Fall In Love Again / Love Theme From "Romeo And Juliet" (A Time For Us) (7", Single)

I'll Never Fall In Love Again / Love Theme From "Romeo And Juliet" (A Time For Us) (7", Single)

$3.21

In Stock

Johnny Mathis - Good Night, Dear Lord

Good Night, Dear Lord

$6.00$7.00

In Stock

Johnny Mathis - Raindrops Keep Fallin' On My Head

Raindrops Keep Fallin' On My Head

$7.00$9.00

In Stock

Johnny Mathis - Heavenly And Faithfully

Heavenly And Faithfully

$6.00

In Stock

Johnny Mathis - Love Theme From "Romeo And Juliet" (A Time For Us)

Love Theme From "Romeo And Juliet" (A Time For Us)

$6.00

In Stock

Johnny Mathis - Me And Mrs. Jones

Me And Mrs. Jones

$6.00$8.00

In Stock

Johnny Mathis - Wonderful! Wonderful!

Wonderful! Wonderful!

$6.00

In Stock

Johnny Mathis - I Only Have Eyes For You

I Only Have Eyes For You

$7.00$9.00

In Stock

Johnny Mathis - Give Me Your Love For Christmas

Give Me Your Love For Christmas

$5.00$10.00

In Stock

Compare prices

Johnny Mathis With Nelson Riddle And His Orchestra - I'll Buy You A Star

I'll Buy You A Star

Johnny Mathis With Nelson Riddle And His Orchestra

$6.00$8.00

In Stock

Johnny Mathis - In Person - Recorded Live At Las Vegas

In Person - Recorded Live At Las Vegas

$7.00

In Stock

Johnny Mathis - Sending You A Little Christmas

Sending You A Little Christmas

$20.00$32.98

In Stock

Compare prices

Johnny Mathis - Christmas With Johnny Mathis

Christmas With Johnny Mathis

$5.00$10.00

In Stock

Compare prices

Johnny Mathis - Johnny's Greatest Hits

Johnny's Greatest Hits

$5.00

In Stock

Compare prices

Johnny Mathis - Christmas Time Is Here

Christmas Time Is Here

$24.01$42.98

In Stock

Compare prices

Johnny Mathis - 33 Greatest Hits

33 Greatest Hits

$30.56$36.99

In Stock

Compare prices

Johnny Mathis - The Very Best Of Johnny Mathis

The Very Best Of Johnny Mathis

$23.99$29.99

In Stock

Compare prices

Johnny Mathis - The Heart Of A Woman

The Heart Of A Woman

$4.99$6.00

In Stock

Compare prices

Johnny Mathis - I'm Coming Home

I'm Coming Home

$4.99$8.00

In Stock

Compare prices

Johnny Mathis - Johnny's Mood

Johnny's Mood

$5.99$13.00

In Stock

Compare prices

Johnny Mathis - Hold Me, Thrill Me, Kiss Me

Hold Me, Thrill Me, Kiss Me

$6.00

In Stock

Compare prices

PreviousPage 3 of 4Next